Armed Conflict — 2026-11-18

Germany and UK Push Back After Pentagon Criticizes Ukraine Deep Strikes Into Russia

BLUFA formal US restriction on Ukraine's use of American weapons, intelligence, or targeting support for strikes inside Russia is very unlikely within the next 30 days; allied pushback and Colby's own caveats favor quiet recalibration over an overt curb.

US Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Elbridge Colby told the 37th Ukraine Defence Contact Group meeting on November 17 that Ukrainian deep strikes, including on civilian targets such as Wildberries, have not helped end the war or slow Russian advances, and have probably hardened Russian resolve and Kremlin willingness to escalate, Ukrainska Pravda reported 1. Colby added that Ukraine should not fight "with its hands tied" and that strikes supporting the front line are acceptable 1. Asked about Colby's position at a Brussels briefing the same day, German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius called such criticism "quite a stupid thing" and redirected attention to Russian strikes on Ukrainian energy, water and heating infrastructure, according to Anadolu Agency 2. Anadolu noted that both Russia and Ukraine deny deliberately targeting civilian infrastructure, and that the remarks followed US-mediated talks in the UAE last week, the first since February, which produced plans for a large-scale prisoner exchange 2. NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte said earlier on November 17 that Ukraine has the right to strike Russian logistical hubs 1.

Analysis
We assess with high confidence, based on consistent reporting from four outlets and no indicator of a policy directive behind Colby's remarks, that Washington is not moving toward a ban. The US government is very unlikely to announce a formal restriction on Ukraine's use of US-supplied weapons, intelligence or targeting support for strikes inside Russia within the next 30 days. Colby's own framing, that front-line support strikes are acceptable, signals a preference for retargeting rather than prohibition, and Berlin, London and Rutte's public backing of Kyiv's right to hit logistical hubs raises the political cost of any formal curb. The Colby quotes trace to a single meeting opening, so the weight rests on that one exchange. Colby's remarks may instead be a signal to steer Ukrainian targeting toward the front line ahead of negotiations, with Washington's quiet review of long-range requests, which leaves no public announcement to observe, as the real lever. If a formal restriction does come, Kyiv and European suppliers would have to reroute deep-strike planning and re-examine reliance on US intelligence. Otherwise, current targeting of Russian logistics and energy sites continues.
4 sources
  1. Pentagon's deputy chief condemns Ukrainian long-range strikes on Russia, saying they "incur pain on Russian population" - Ukrainska Pravda
  2. Germany rejects US criticism of Ukraine's deep strikes inside Russia - Anadolu Agency
  3. Germany, UK push back after US criticizes Ukraine's deep strikes into Russia - Kyiv Independent
  4. German Minister Rejects US Criticism of Kyiv's Deep Strikes as 'Stupid' - U.S. News & World Report (Reuters)

View in full brief →

UNCLASSIFIED // OPEN SOURCE